|
Understanding
and Recognising ADHD
Dr Nikos Myttas
Consultant Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist
London
A distinct group of children exists who have trouble staying with any task
for any length of time unless they receive constant feedback, stimulation and
reward or have close, one-to-one supervision. They fleet from activity to
activity, hardly ever completing any. They are either distractible or hyperfocused and they lose their train of thought easily.
They get muddled up and they have difficulty getting back on track. They
daydream, they appear not to listen, they lose or misplace their things and
they forget instructions. They procrastinate, avoiding tasks that demand
attention and sustained concentration. They have a poor sense of time and
priorities. They are moody and constantly complaining of boredom, yet they
have trouble initiating activities. They are full of energy as if 'driven by
a motor', restless, constantly fidgeting, tapping, touching or fiddling with
something and they may have difficulty getting off to sleep. They speak and
act without thinking, they cut across the conversations of others, they have
difficulty waiting for their turn, they shout out in class, they disrupt
others and they rush through their work making careless mistakes. They
misjudge social situations, they dominate their peers, and they are loud and
act silly in crowds to the embarrassment of their parents. They are demanding
and cannot take 'no' for an answer. Putting off immediate rewards for
delayed, but larger, ones sets them off in a spin.
These children are repeatedly described as 'lazy', 'underachievers', 'not
reaching their potential', 'unpredictable', 'disorganized', 'erratic',
'loud', 'unfocused', 'scatterbrained', 'undisciplined' and 'uncontained'.
Their teachers' reports are testimony to these labels. At the same time, they
can be bright, creative, articulate, lateral thinkers, imaginative and
loving.
What is often implied but not stated is that their parents are to blame.
These parents are thought to be ineffective, uncontaining
of their children, with pathological attachment, unable to exercise
discipline or teach manners, harbouring unconscious repressed feelings of
hatred against their children, often the result of their own deprived
childhood. Yet the same parents may be bringing up several other children
with no signs of distress or maladjustment in them. Guilt is almost
synonymous with parenthood and it is extremely rare that a parent will resist
such an attack and challenge it, especially if it comes from a professional.
History
The restless, overactive and fidgety child who stands out from his peers has
been around, presumably, as long as children have been around. The first
known reference to a hyperactive child or one with attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) occurs in the poems of the German physician
Heinrich Hoffman, who in 1865 described 'fidgety Philip' as one who 'won't
sit still, wriggles, giggles, swings backwards and forwards, tilts up his
chair... growing rude and wild'.
In 1902 the paediatrician, George Still, presented a series of three lectures
to the Royal Society of Medicine describing 43 children from his clinical
practice who were often aggressive, defiant, resistant to discipline,
excessively emotional or passionate, who showed little inhibitory volition,
had serious problems with sustained attention and could not learn from the
consequences of their actions. Still proposed that the deficits in inhibitory
volition, moral control and sustained attention were causally related to each
other and to the same underlying neurological deficit. He speculated that
these children had either a low threshold for response inhibition or a
cortical disconnection syndrome where intellect was dissociated from will,
possibly due to nerve cell changes. The children described by Still, and by Tredgold (1908) soon after, would today be diagnosed as
suffering from ADHD with associated oppositional defiant disorder or conduct
disorder.
Clinical presentation
Although ADHD is a heterogeneous condition occurring along a continuum of
severity, a fairly typical presentation is a child who has been difficult to
handle, often since birth and certainly before school entry. As infants, some
may have been extremely difficult to settle at night. They may have had their
parents pacing up and down the room for hours while holding them, in order
for them to fall asleep. Their parents may even have taken them in the car
and driven them around to get them to sleep. Many would sleep in short
bursts, be full of energy upon waking, extremely demanding of constant
stimulation and needing to be picked up and held for long periods of time.
As soon as these children can walk they may be into anything, sometimes
clumsily. They climb, run about and get into accidents. At preschool they
stand out as restless. They are unable to sit down during story time, they fight with others, spit, scratch, take
unnecessary risks without a sense of fear and fail to respond to punishment.
At the start of formal education they might be, in addition to the above,
messy and disorganized with their work, overtalkative
in class and forgetful. They may interrupt the lesson and interfere with the
work of others, get up from their seats, walk about, rock on their chairs,
make noises, constantly fiddle, be unable to pay attention or be in a daze.
During playtime they may have difficulty sharing and negotiating
relationships with their classmates. They tend to dominate the game, be
inflexible and particularly loud, and break up the games of others if not
allowed in. Some would have such difficulty making and keeping friendships and
they would rarely get invited to parties, if at all.
At home they may wind up their brothers or sisters, refuse to help out or
comply with demands, complain of boredom, get into mischief, set fires or
engage in other dangerous activities in the pursuit of excitement.
Diagnosis
Although there is no clear demarcation between temperamentally impulsive,
active and inattentive children and those who suffer from ADHD, those
children whose behaviour interferes with their learning, social adjustment,
peer relationships, self-esteem and family functioning warrant a thorough
investigation. Arriving at a diagnosis is a lengthy and painstaking process
based on a systematic, comprehensive, thorough and detailed neuropsychiatric
work up, observation of the child in the school setting, and exclusion of
medical conditions or circumstances that might produce a similar picture or
exacerbate pre-existing ADHD. The symptoms must not be better accounted for
by other psychiatric conditions (such a mood, anxiety, personality or
dissociative disorders).
The definition and criteria for diagnosing ADHD are similar, but not
identical, in both the international classification of diseases (ICD-10)
(WHO, 1994) and the fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) (American Psychiatric Association, 1994). The
list of criteria for inattentiveness, overactivity
and impulsivity is short but comprehensive. It is stipulated that the
symptoms must have had an early onset (mean age is 4 years) and must have
been present for more than 6 months, occurring across situations and falling
along a continuum (deviant from age-based standards).
Co-morbidity
All too often the unitary approach to diagnosing neuropsychiatric conditions
prevails, and other co-morbid conditions are either overlooked or not
paid sufficient attention. Because ADHD is a significant educational, social
and emotional handicap, it is exceptional rather than the rule that it exists
in pure form. Over 50% of sufferers will have either one or more of the
following conditions at the same time (Bird et al, 1993):
- Specific learning difficulties
- Conduct disorder
- Oppositional defiant disorder
- Anxiety disorder
- Affective disorder
- Substance abuse
- Developmental language delay
- Obsessive compulsive disorder
- Asperger
syndrome
- Tic disorder
- Tourette's
syndrome
The degree of impairment depends
on the type and number of co-existing conditions, which may require different
or additional treatment. Co-morbidity does not explain causality; it merely
states that two or more conditions are present at the same time.
Epidemiology
The prevalence of ADHD used to be considerably different in the US and the
UK, partly because of individual rigidity in applying clinical standards and
partly owing to national practices. Historically, UK clinicians have been
suspicious of ADHD as a primary condition and, therefore, approaches to
diagnostic assessment vary widely between practitioners and centres. A rapprochment between the US and UK has emerged lately,
made possible by the convergence of the diagnostic criteria of the ICD-10 and
DSM-IV. This new consensus estimates prevalence in the UK at 6-8% of the
child population, compared with 3-5% of UK children.
As with most neuropsychiatric conditions, the ratio of boys to girls is 3:1,
with no social, economic or ethnic group bias in the general child
population. However, in mental health clinics the ratio rises to between 6:1
and 9:1 (Cantwell, 1996) owing to referral bias (boys get referred more because
they are more aggressive).
DSM-IV distinguishes three types of ADHD:
- Predominantly hyperactive-impulsive
- Predominantly inattentive
- Both hyperactive-impulsive and inattentive combined
The prevalence ratio is 3:1:2 in
clinic populations and 1:2:1 in diagnosed community samples (Mash and
Barkley, 1998). This suggests that the purely inattentive type is least
likely to be identified and that screening for a possible diagnosis of
attention deficit disorder (ADD) also occurs less often.
ADHD with hyperactivity
ADD is much less common (possibly about 1%). It is likely to be an entity
distinct from ADHD, perhaps more akin to a learning difficulty. ADD sufferers
are mostly girls, characterized by anxiety, sluggishness and daydreaming.
They are less aggressive, overactive or impulsive, better at making and
keeping friendships and their academic performance is worse in tests that
involve perceptual-motor speed. Because they do not display the degree of
behavioural disturbance boys do, they do not get referred as often as they
should. When they do, they are more likely to be misdiagnosed.
Current aetiological theories
No evidence exists to suggest that ADHD is caused by other than
neurobiological malfunctioning. Although environmental factors may influence
the course of the disorder over a lifetime, they do not bring the condition
about. The significance of several anatomical and neurochemical
abnormalities is still unclear. These include deficits in dopamine-decarboxylase in the anterior frontal cortex, leading to
reduced dopamine availability and diminished focusing and attention; more
symmetrical brains; smaller-sized brains in the area of the prefrontal cortex
(caudate, globus pallidus);
duplication polymorphism in the DRD4 and DAT genes.
The prevailing theory that tries to explain ADHD implicates the frontal
cortex and its importance in response inhibition. ADHD sufferers have
difficulty in suppressing impulse. Therefore, they respond to all impulses,
being unable to exclude those that are unnecessary for the situation. Rather
than failing to pay attention, they pay more attention to more cues than the
average person, and are unable to stop the relentless flow of information.
These people fail to pause, to consider the situation, options and consequences
before exercising volition. Instead they act without thinking. They
frequently report that they function best when caught 'in the thrill of it
all' whatever the 'all' may be.
There is strong evidence for a genetic predisposition to ADHD with a concordance
rate in monozygotic twins ranging from 75-91% (Goodman and Stevenson, 1989).
One third of affected individuals have at least one parent who suffers from
the same condition. Non-genetic factors that have been found to predispose
people to developing ADHD are low birth weight (
<1500g), environmental toxins, tobacco, alcohol and cocaine abuse during pregnancy (Milberger et al, 1996). >
ADHD across the lifespan
Children with ADHD do not grow out of it. Between 70-80% carry the condition
into their adult life to a varying degree (Klein and Mannuzza,
1991). Early identification and multimodal treatment reduces the risk of
developing further complications such as antisocial behaviour, abuse of
alcohol, tobacco and illicit substances, poor academic and social
functioning, and further psychiatric morbidity.
References
American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders, 4th edn. APA, Washington
DC.
Biederman J, Faraone SV,
Spencer T, Wilens TE, Norman D, Lapey
KA, Mick E, Kricher B, Doyle A 91993) Patterns of
psychiatric comorbidity, cognition and psychosocial
functioning in adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Am J
Psychiatry 150(12): 1792-8
Bird HR, Gould MS Stagezza BM (1993) Patterns of
psychiatric comorbidity in a community sample of
children aged 9 through 16 years. J Am Acad
Child Adolesc Psychiatry 148: 361-8
Cantwell D (1996) Attention deficit disorder: a review of the past 10
years. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
Psychiatry 35: 978-87
Goodman R, Stevenson JA (1989) Twin study of hyperactive II. The etiological
role of genes, family relationships and prenatal adversity. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 5: 691
Klein RG, Mannuzza S (1991) Long-term outcome of
hyperactive children: a review. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 30: 383-7
Mash EJ, Barkley RA (1998) Treatment of Childhood Disorders, 2nd edn. Guilford, New York
Milberger S, Biererman J,
Faraone SV, Chen L, Jones J (1996) Is maternal
smoking a risk factor for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in
children? Am J Psychiatry 153: 1138-42
Still GF (1902) Some abnormal psychical conditions in children Lancet
1: 1008-12, 1077-82, 1163-68
Tredgold AF (1908) Mental Deficiency (Amentia).
W Wood, New York
World Health Organization (1992) The ICD-10 classification of mental and
behavioural disorders: Clinical descriptions and diagnostic guidelines. WHO,
Geneva.
Further Information
ADDISS
(Attention Deficit Disorder Information Service)
(Registered charity 1070827)
79 The Burroughs
Hendon
London
NW4 4AX
Tel 020 8952 2800
Children and Adults with Attention Deficit Disorder (ChADD)
(American ADHD website)
www.chadd.org
Adders
(UK ADHD website)
www.adders.org
Further Reading
Barkley RA (1998) Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: A Handbook for
Diagnosis and Treatment. The Guilford Press, New York
Cooper P, Ideus K (1995) Attention Deficit
Hyperactivity Disorder: A Practical Guide for Teachers. David Fulton
Publisher, New York
Hallowell EM, Ratey JJ (1994) Driven to
Distraction. Pantheon Books, New York
Taylor E, Chadwick Q, Hepinstall E, Danckaerts M
(1998) Hyperactivity and conduct problems as risk factors for adolescent
development. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
Psychiatry 35: 1213-26
Weiss G (1993) Hyperactive Children Grown Up, 2nd edn.
Guilford Press, New York.
This article is reproduced
courtesy of Practice Nursing. (Practice Nursing 2001, Volume 12, number 7,
pages 278-280).
Back to top of page
|
Key
Points
- ADHD is a genetically determined, neuropsychiatric
condition
- ADHD constitutes a major educational, social,
cognitive and emotional handicap for those affected
- The major symptoms of ADHD persist throughout life in
most people who are affected
- People with ADHD run a high risk of alcohol and
substance abuse, criminal behaviour, poor psychosocial functioning and
psychiatric disorders
- Early intervention and treatment significantly
reduces the risk of further psychosocial complications
Phone: 020 8906 9068
Fax: 020 8959 0727
e-mail: info@addiss.co.uk
ADDISS
PO Box 340
Edgware
Middlesex HA8 9HL
Registered Charity 1070827
|